I have shot at every venue on this list. I know which suites have AM window light at Grand View, where the dock photographs at golden hour at Madden's, which corner of the Whitefish Lodge banquet room turns hostile during a 2:00 ceremony. The notes below are what I would tell a friend, not what a venue's marketing site would tell a stranger.
Every entry includes who the venue is right for — and who should skip it. If a venue is wrong for your guest count, your aesthetic, or your budget, the photographs will tell that story. The first job of this guide is to help you avoid that.
For deeper coverage of any venue (insider light timing, ceremony space breakdowns, sample timelines), follow the venue link to the dedicated page.